Marble bust of Aristotle. Roman copy after a Greek bronze original by Lysippus c. 330 BC. The alabaster mantle is modern.The last issue that I will deal with, in this paper is, as we first introduced, anagnorisis and catharsis. I will briefly answer the following questions, after introduce what anagnoris and catharsis means regarding theatre.

Anagnorisis, firstly set by Aristotle, occurs, when, a character, usually the main character, discovers something that before he didn’t know, and this makes him or her, have a different vision of everything happened.

Catharsis, firstly set by Aristotle as he did with anagnorisis, refers to purification and purgation of emotions through fear and pity. The spectator identifies himself with an actor and through feeling fear to him or pity to him, the spectator feels purified if the actor success in what is trying to achieve.

¿When the anagnorisis is produced in A woman of no importance? Well, it’s easy to focus on when anagnorisis is produced in this play. Nobody could doubt that anagnorisis is clearly produced when lady Arbuthnot says to her son Gerald the truth about who lord Illingworth really is.

Lady Arbuthnot: Stop, Gerald, stop! He is your own father! (Act III, p. 58)7

Wilde, combines like a genius, a part of the play in which, basically, as we mentioned at the beginning of the paper, doesn’t occurs anything unusual, within the extreme scene of “he is your father” in act III. Wilde, reaches, at the same time, to catch the spectators attention, and also to introduce the axis issue of the play. Anagnorisis and excitement.

¿How the dramatist success in produce us catharsis feeling? We, as readers or spectators, in this play, experience catharsis at the end of it. When Gerald and Esther are promised and lady Arbuthnot feels free because she said Gerald the whole truth and Gerald still loves her.

We feel catharsis, inter alia, because our today’s society see as equals women and men, and we don’t much agree the idea of a woman punished during her whole life because of her past. On the other hand, Iuri Tinnianov introduced the idea that each work, should be studied according the culture and epoch of each reader.15 A play by Oscar Wilde, isn’t received by a X century reader, in the same way that a XXI century reader would receive it.

Moreover, an interesting characteristic that guided the reader or spectator to feel that catharsis is a monologue of Esther Worsley, who said to lady Arbuthnot, and I will repeat an example quoted above, but I think it’s a key speech in the play.

Hester: […] If a man and a woman have sinned, let them both go forth into the desert to love or loathe each other there. Let them both be branded. Set a mark, if you wish, on each, but don’t punish the one and let the other go free. Don’t have a law for men and another for women. You are unjust to women in England…(Act II, pp. 46)7

We agree that idea, and we identifies ourselves within Arbuthnot’s character.

Oscar Wilde, during the whole play is guiding us, to punish Illingworth’s behavior, and to applaud Arbuthnot’s one. He does it, mainly portraying lord Ilingworth as a rich and pervert man, whilst Arbuthnot is said to be perfect, pure, in brief, extraordinary but punished by her past.

Statue of Oscar Wilde in Merrion Square, Dublin. The materials are granite, green nephrite jade, white jadeite and thuliteDespite there are many features to deal with when talking about «curious features of Oscar Wilde’s plays» We are going to show only the most two noticeable examples, these are, the repetition of words by Lady Stutfield. Wilde portrays Lady Stutfielf as a woman with few vocabulary and who does not know almost anything about life, she agrees with everybody because she have never been preocupied for learning anything. We will also focus on the figure of Lady Hunstanton, the house host, a person who, as usually in her social position, wants to know about anything, but I’m not referring to anything, including science, maths, language, literature, no, I’m referring that she wants to know about everything about others life, others ideas, others intentions.Otherwise, she seems to have acumulated too much gossips during his whole life that she’s a forgetful character, or at least, Wilde represent her that way.

Notice here, the parañlelism between someone’s else words, and Lady Stutfield ones, she’s like a human parrot.

Señora Allonby:  The trees are wonderful, Lady Hunstanton.

Lady Stutfield: Quite, quite wonderful. (Act I, p. 6)7

Lady Stutfield: How quite, quite nice of them. (Act I, p. 7)7

Lady Stutfield: Yes; that is quite, quite true. I had not thought of that. (Act I, p. 7)7

As I have mentioned above, she seems to have no own ideas about almost anything, in contrast to Lord Illingworth, the dandy, or Hester Worsley that manifests her own ideas all the time.

Another interesting feature is, how Wilde portrays lady Hunstanton’s character, she is the sort of aristocratic woman that has nothing more interesting to do than gossiping everybody, but she also seem not to pay much attention of what she heard, and she had heard a lot of gossips, that’s why she doesn’t remember many things.

Lady Hunstanton:  No, dear, he was killed in the hunting field. Or was it fishing, Caroline? I forget. But George came in for everything. I always tell him that no younger son has ever had such good luck as he has had. (Act II, p. 32)7

 Lady Hunstanton: Ah! dear Lady Stutfield! and what has Mr. Kelvil been talking to you about?

Lady Stutfield: . About Bimetallism, as well as I remember.

Lady Hunstanton:  Bimetallism! Is that quite a nice subject? However, I know people discuss everything very freely nowadays. What did Sir John talk to you about, dear Mrs. Allonby? (Act III, p. 48)7

These examples reflect perfectly how lady Hunstanton is, her nature. Gossip, and forgetful.

Through this examples, Oscar Wilde reflects a Victorian Era society in which the most important thing isn’t the knowledge itself, but think highly of the good ideas and know as much «irrelevant» things as you can.

Let’s switch to another issue, stage directions.

The importance of stage directions is such big as character thoughts in Shakespeare’s play Hamlet. If we eliminate stage directions, we are eliminating the own author’s vision of his play, deleting that communication system cancels the original creator’s concept.15 For example, in many plays by Oscar Wilde, at the beginning of each act, there is a large stage direction that guides the director when performing the story, the director must follow the author’s instructions to do it.(Besides, In A woman of no importance, there are the shortest stage directions at the beginning of each text of all his plays)

Lawn in front of the terrace at Hunstanton.

(Sir John and Lady Caroline Pontefract, Miss Worsley, on chairs under large yew tree). (Act I, p. 2)7

Drawing-room at Hunstanton, after dinner, lamps lit. Door L.C. Door R.C.

(Ladies seated on sofas). (Act II, p. 35)7

We see that, Wilde, in his notes, doesn’t refer to how the characters dress or act but he emphasizes how the scenery looks like. That’s why the play is an actual play, at that time, of course, and the stage directors also knew what kind of clothes wore each character and how each character should act.

Despite this kind of stage direction, the ones at the beginning of each act or scene, it’s necessary to pay attention to another sort of “between-acts-stage-directions”. It is, the notes that the authors write down throughout the play to make easier to perform the material play into a theatrical play, with characters, scenery, public, lights, etc… However, classical authors, from Greek and Elizabeth eras, and many others, didn’t write stage directions. Using stage directions become usually around the late XIX century with modern authors, the golden era of Oscar Wilde.

Here you are some examples:

Gerald: (Slowly). I suppose there is. (Act III, p. 43)7

Gerald: (To Lord Illingworth). Do speak to my mother, Lord Illingworth, before you go into the music-room. She seems to think, somehow, you don’t mean what you said to me. (Act II, p. 36)7

Lady Arbuthnot: The Puritan, Lord Illingworth. (A pause)

(Winces, then rises slowly and goes over to table where his hat and gloves are. Mrs. Arbuthnot is standing close to the table. He picks up one of the gloves, and begins pulling it on). (Act IV, p. 75)7

As we can see, there are both, long and short stage directions, however, according to Louis E. Cartron, those “between-act-stage-directions” that we mentioned above, are named “actor direction” because, those notes are regarded to actors, in order to adapt their movements, gests, their speech, to the author’s volition, the other ones, which are related to the scenery, are called “stage directions”.16

Back to Wilde way of structuring his plays, he uses lots of actor directions. A reason is because his plays were written to be represented on scene, he should make easy the director to perform a good theatrical piece, because, if not, he won’t be paid at all. A second reasons is because A woman of no importance , as usually in many others of his plays, needs these stage directions and actor directions. The whole play is a dialogue between aristocrats, they talk and talk, so, it’s important to mark, to who is talking each character, when some of them laugh, when somebody moves, or even when somebody look some character else because of a comment he or she did.

Another relevant issue in order to talk about Wilde’s dramaturgy is “industry and commercialization”. We all know that,

Another relevant issue in order to talk about Wilde’s dramaturgy is “industry and commercialization”. We all know that, capitalism changes our “modus operandi” and adapt us to what is expected of us to be, and to do(Today, on late-capitalism, we have many examples of that changes). In this sense, Wilde, as a playwright, may have created plays, not according to his own ideas, but his chief volition, but, somehow, the author always expresses himself in between lines.

According to a work by Ignacio Ramos Gay, theatre in the second half of the XIX century was, basically, commercial theatre. It was a business, somehow, as today is. He says, “La necesaria búsqueda de obras que se mantengan en cartel durante largo tiempo

repercute por igual en la naturaleza de la obra misma –escrita, como ya hemos dicho, de

manera prefabricada, atendiendo a diversos parámetros siempre ajenos a la creación

personal…”13 It seems that Wilde’s abilities and, his message, were castrated by commercialism and capitalism, otherwise, we could interpret it from an opposite point of view, this way through, Wilde was able to show his ideas to the people, he was not castrated, but helped by commercial theatre. Anyway, he was not free to write whatever that was in his mind.

 

The play, key of our study, was written to be represented on stage, as we’ve argued before, and so did An ideal husband and Salomé among others. Wilde, was asked by Sr. H. Beerbohm Tree to write a play which he, as a businessman and director could represent, and, a play which, one of its main characters was, somehow, as Sr. Tree was. Wilde joined his idea and wrote A woman of no importance. This way, the author isn’t so free; he must write his play attending orders.

Let me show you how difficult was to be a playwright in the Victorian era, key example of the “slavery” they suffered.

…his first difficulty consists in pleasing Himself –his second difficulty in pleasing the Manager –his third, in pleasing the Actors –his fourth, in pleasing the Licenser –his fifth, in pleasing the Audience –his sixth, in pleasing the Newspapers; and, in addition to all these, the actors must please not to be taken ill, the weather must please not to be unfavorable, the opposing theatre must please not to put up strong bills; and then! –what then? –why then –“Please to pay the bearer the small sum of * * *” and, N.B. which sum is sometimes, par accident, not paid at all.14

Above all, the last XIX century is known as the period of transition from romantic tragedy to domestic Victorian drama. It was called, the domestic Victorian drama, “Society drama”. Society drama wasn’t free at all to write about whatever they wanted, they were commercial authors, and the main point was to make spectators enjoy the representation. So, spectators didn’t want to see repugnant aspects of life, they were willed to see how beautiful the life was. Because of this, society drama was hardly censured. It was thought to be dangerous because representations included scenes of: “mujeres casadas descontentas, en un estado permanente de rebellion, no solo contra la conduction que la naturaleza ha impuesto a su sexo, sino tambien contra todos los deberes y objetivos de esposas y madres…”8 It is, exactly, what Oscar Wilde has writen about in A woman of no importance.

He is a representative figure of that kind of drama.

An interesting feature of society drama that I would like to mention related to Oscar Wilde dramaturgy is, “the woman with a past”(Understanding by “past”, sexual activity before and after wedding). This “past” doesn’t allow women to find happiness. Besides, that women were extremely rejected by the whole society, whilst men weren’t(double standard).9

Lady Arbuthnot: Gerald, come near to me. Quite close to me, as you used to do when you were a little boy, when you were mother’s own boy. (Gerald sits down betide his mother. She runs her fingers through his hair, and strokes his hands). Gerald, there was a girl once, she was very young, she was little over eighteen at the time. George Harford – that was Lord Illingworth’s name then – George Harford met her. She knew nothing about life. He – knew everything. He made this girl love him. He made her love him so much that she left her father’s house with him one morning. […]Before her child was born – for she had a child – she implored him for the child’s sake to marry her, that the child might have a name…

Lady Gerald:  My dear mother, it all sounds very tragic, of course. But I dare say the girl was just as much to blame as Lord Illingworth was. – After all, would a really nice girl, a girl with any nice feelings at all, go away from her home with a man to whom she was not married, and live with him as his wife? No nice girl would. (Act III, p. 57)7

You should have noticed how women were rejected, how they were seen as sinful, they’re thought not to deserve anything, whilst nobody mentions the men’s sin. You should also have noticed the idea of “the woman with a past”. Lady Arbuthnot “did wrong” in the past, and now, that past is still troubling her. She is even ashamed of her past, that’s why she hides herself into an eighteen years old woman.

Wilde, his genius, reflects this idea of woman/past perfectly since the first dialogue of lady Arbuthnot, she’s portrayed as antiquated , educated, beautiful, but, unhappy.

However, the most important aspect in A woman of no importance isn’t “the woman with a past” but, according to Historia crítica del teatro ingles, its verbal and epigrammatic aspect, “en un primer acto carente de acción durante el cual, los personajes aristocráticos reunidos en la “country house” componen una autentica sinfonía de ingeniosidades”.10 In this line, Karl Beckson wrote a few words about the acts action. He says,”How different is the “He is your father!” tableau at the end of act III from the strong and simple conclusion of act II, how different and how inferior!”.11 Many critics have seen this action-lack. That’s why Richard Ellmann concludes that A woman of no importance is the weakest play of Oscar Wilde.12

On the other hand, it’s curious the role that Wilde provides to some of his play’s characters. In our play, I’m referring to Hester Worsley(North-American). She’s the one who in some moment of the play judges what has been said. She’s a high moral character. This kind of moral character also appears in Lady Windermere’s fan and An ideal husband. Using this characters, Wilde always introduces an alternative to what is happening or has happened. For instance, in A woman of no importance, introduces a different point of view of the “double standard” way of acting ingrained in England.10

Hester: […] If a man and a woman have sinned, let them both go forth into the desert to love or loathe each other there. Let them both be branded. Set a mark, if you wish, on each, but don’t punish the one and let the other go free. Don’t have a law for men and another for women. You are unjust to women in England…(Act II, pp. 46)7

As Hester character is the portrayal of moral thinking, she provides an alternative more morally acceptable, despite not being accepted in England XIX century.

1881 caricature in Punch, the caption reads: "O.W.", "Oh, I eel just as happy as a bright sunflower, Lays of Christy Minstrelsy, "Æsthete of Æsthetes!/What's in a name!/The Poet is Wilde/But his poetry's tame."

Aestheticism movement basically emphasizes artistic values (Art for art’s sake), above other values as morality or society usefulness of a literary work. It has post-romantic roots and anticipates modernism. This movement was developed around 1868-1891, and it’s supposed to end in 1895 with the judgment of Oscar Wilde.1

As for many others,  Walter Pater was an influence for Oscar Wilde, he very important in the aestheticism movement, and he used to say, “Life should be lived intensely, following the beautifulness ideal”.2

Aestheticism precursors were, inter alia, John Keats y Percy Bysshe Shelley, and the most representative authors besides Oscar Wilde were, Algernon Charles Swinburne, they both influenced by French symbolism and James McNeill Whistler.

These authors of aestheticism literature have been satirized by humoristic magazines as Punch.

Basically, the whole play could be considered as an example of aestheticism, because Wilde wrote about a house, and some guests spending their life quietly. This work is only written to entertain a public and readers, to pleasure them, not to teach a moral or religious lesson. As we said before, “art for art’s sake”.

On the other hand, there was a literary movement started in French(1880-1900), called the decadent movement. This name, “decadent” comes from a contempt and ironic term used by the critics.

Decadent movement arises because of the economical transition. “basada en la libre concurrencia a la economía de las grandes concentraciones financieras e industriales que se manifestó en un estancamiento económico que daría lugar a la renovación del sistema productivo, a la represión de las masas populares y la preocupación por las cuestiones de tipo social”.3

What the term decadent means regarding art is to be linked to reactionary positions, elitists, aristocratic, etc.4

Morally, decadent word is related to a way of life sensualist, hedonistic, and every kind of excesses all types.5

What I mean is that, depending on the point of view you apply in order to analyze this movement, it may changes our whole conception of it.

There are many authors that joined this movement6, Oscar Wilde, Theodore William Graf Wratislaw from England. Léon Bloy and Jean Lombard from France. Ramón María del Valle Inclán Bermudez de Castro and Salvador Rueda y Santos from Spain.

Despite the most important decadent work of Oscar Wilde is The picture of Dorian Gray, we can also find features of this movement in A woman of no importance.

Lady Caroline: Ah, yes! the young man who has a post in a bank. Lady Hunstanton is most kind in asking him here, and Lord Illingworth seems to have taken quite a fancy to him. I am not sure, however, that Jane is right in taking him out of his position. In my young days, Miss Worsley, one never met anyone in society who worked for their living. It was not considered the thing.

Señorita Esther:  In America those are the people we respect most. (Act I, p. 3)7

Oscar Wilde, here, is criticizing and putting forward what is considered an error by Wilde, it is, feeding the higher class, whilst lower classes are starving in the street.

Another clearer example could be:

Lady Hunstanton: Politics are in a sad way everywhere, I am told. They certainly are in England. Dear Mr. Cardew is ruining the country. I wonder Mrs. Cardew allows him. I am sure, Lord Illingworth, you don’t think that uneducated people should be allowed to have votes?  (Act I, p. 10)7

Now, he’s criticizing politicians all around the world, and specifically in England.

00 Introduction

8 maig, 2013

The young man you can see in the image above is Oscar Wilde, a dramatist, novelist and also poet and a sort of philosofer of the late nineteen century. Famous for works as, The importance of being Ernest, The picture of Dorian Gray, A woman of no importance, Salomé, and so on.

Why have I chosen this topic and this author? I decided to deal with Oscar wilde and to approach his dramaturgy, his way of doing and structuring drama, beccause, somehow i knew that his plays are quite unique, so, it seemed to me such a proper topic to deal with, in order to find out why these plays are so special. The play which I have chosen to approach this topic is one of his most famous plays, even though it’s thought as the weakest of all his plays, A woman of no importance. I have selected this play because it’s not either a classical play nor a contemporary one, but it was writen during the nineteen century, in the so called Victorian Era. Time-frame that as you may know saw how the theatre evolved and evolved until being one of the main entertainment element in that epoch, it was because the comercialization of drama, we will talk about it later.

What do I expecto to find out through analyzing this play and this topic? His dramaturgy, of course, and this means that I expect to better know about dramatical strategies that he used, also to know which was the literary movement or movements that were ruling in the XIX century in the england of Oscar Wilde, I would also like to achieve a conception of how he used the usual theatrical features as, stage directions, and the division of acts and scenes of his plays and also how he managed the entries and exits of characters.

To analyze that concepts mentioned above, we’ll pay special attention to the dramatic features of Oscar Wilde’s epoch, focusing on  the so called society drama. We will also deal with the commercialization of theatre focusing on the effects that it may have had to drama, for example, lost of freedom to write about whatever the dramatist wants.  We’ll  talk about stage directions, entries and exits of characters, and  acts and scenes too, then we will deal with some particular features of Oscar Wilde when writing a play. The last issue we will deal with is the anagnorisis and catharsis, from a personal view, of course, because despite the playwright intention each reader conceives the play individually, the so called: Reader-response criticism first treated by Felix Vodicka. To briefly analyze those concepts, anagnorisis and catharsis, I will question myself: When the anagnorisis is produced, and how the dramatist success in provoke us this feeling.

First of all, I would like to feel free to talk really shortly about something I consider relevant when approaching every literary work. I mean the literary movement that is ruling in the author’s epoch. On this occasion, we must talk about aestheticism and decadent movement.